We accept the following buy now, pay later services: Klarna, Affirm, and Sunbit.

Logo
phone icon | Lou's Car Care Center
location pin icon | Lou's Car Care

Loading ...

Missing business hours data / Error occurred while getting the data.

clock icon | Lou's Car Care
MY GARAGE
You do not have My Garage enabled.
Section under maintenance.
SCHEDULE AN APPOINTMENT

We accept the following buy now, pay later services: Klarna, Affirm, and Sunbit.

Hours of Operation:

Loading ...

Missing business hours data / Error occurred while getting the data.

When Should I Replace A Tire Instead Of Repairing It?

February 24, 2025

Flat tire on black vehicle in the shop | Lou's Car Care Center, Inc.

Your vehicle's tires are crucial for safety, performance, and efficiency. When you get a flat or notice tire damage, the big question arises: “Should you repair or replace the tire”? While some punctures can be fixed, others require a full replacement to keep you safe on the road. Here’s how to know when it's time for a new tire instead of a simple repair.

 

 

WHEN CAN A TIRE BE REPAIRED?

 

A tire can usually be repaired if:

  • The puncture is less than 1/4 inch in diameter.
  • The damage is located on the tread and not the sidewall or shoulder.
  • There is no visible sidewall bulging or structural damage.
  • The tire has not been driven on while flat, which can cause internal damage.

 

For small punctures within the tread area, a professional plug and patch repair can extend the tire's life. However, if the damage goes beyond these criteria, replacement may be necessary.

Technician replacing tire on wheel rim | Lou's Car Care Center, Inc.


WHEN SHOULD YOU REPLACE A TIRE?

 

1. Puncture Is Too Large or in the Wrong Spot

If a hole is larger than 1/4 inch or located on the sidewall or shoulder, the tire is not safe to repair. The sidewall flexes while driving, making it impossible for a patch to hold properly.

 

2. The Tread Is Too Worn Down

If your tread depth is less than 2/32 of an inch, the tire should be replaced, even if the damage is minor. Bald tires reduce traction, increase stopping distances, and are dangerous in wet or icy conditions.

 

3. Multiple Repairs or Severe Damage

A tire that has been repaired multiple times may no longer be safe. If punctures are too close together or overlap, replacing the tire is a better option. Additionally, if you see cuts, sidewall bulges, or cracks, replacement is the safest choice.

 

4. Damage from a Blowout or Impact

If your tire suffered a blowout or was damaged by hitting a pothole, curb, or debris, internal damage may not be visible. A professional inspection is necessary, but replacement is often the best choice.

 

5. Uneven or Excessive Wear

If your tire shows signs of uneven wear (e.g., excessive wear on one side), it could indicate an alignment issue. While rotating or balancing your tires may help in some cases, severe wear means replacement is the best option.



Tire on shop floor on side of vehicle | Lou's Car Care Center, Inc.


Have more questions about your vehicle's tires? We can help! Lou's Car Care & Fleet Services has been proudly serving Baldwinsville, NY, and surrounding communities since 1976. Call us or schedule your next appointment online today! 



SHEDULE AN APPOINTMENT




Let's Connect! Click on the links below to stay in touch with the Lou's Car Care Community:

Share by: